The testimony of Rabbi Jessica Shimberg, spiritual leader of The Little Minyan Kehilah (Columbus), against the six-week abortion ban (Senate Bill 23) in the 133rd General Assembly. Watch all the testimonies here and here.
Good afternoon, Chairman Merrin and Ranking Member Boyd.
I am Rabbi Jessica Shimberg. I serve as the spiritual leader of The Little Minyan Kehilah in Columbus, Ohio, and work extensively in interfaith spaces and conversations designed to strengthen the fabric of our communities.
A central Ohio resident for nearly all my life, I come before you today as an engaged citizen and faith leader to implore that you consider the ways in which a number of you are using your sense of Christian values to violate the religious liberties of many Ohioans.
As a rabbi and pastoral counselor, a former attorney, mediator and facilitator of conﬂict resolution, and a mother of two college-age sons, I beseech you to oppose S.B. 23, which violates Jewish values and ethics.
In the Torah, the chief biblical source referring to abortion is Exodus 21:22–25, concerning the man who inadvertently strikes a pregnant woman, causing her to lose the pregnancy. The attacker is not liable for homicide for the death of the fetus. However, if the woman dies, the man is liable for her homicide.
In translating the Hebrew text into Greek, the Septuagint ascribed a word referencing the mother as referring to the fetus and its stage of development. (That is, if the fetus had reached a certain stage of development of identiﬁable human formation, the attacker was liable for its death.) The Septuagint translation was the beginning of the separate approaches on the topic of abortion within Judaism and Christianity (which later set quickening, i.e. fetal movement, as the criterion for sufﬁcient formation and later, as it became even more prescriptive, equated conception with formation).
In Judaism, however, full human status is still considered to manifest at birth. The Hellenistic position and that of the early church stand in opposition to the position which became normative Jewish law. Jewish values prioritize the life of a woman over that of an unborn fetus, and although we treat decisions about a fetus with great care and weight, the woman’s health is paramount.
We have come a long way in how we treat women and girls in America. And although orthodoxy and extremism in Judaism, just as in Christianity and Islam, have attempted to exercise increasing control over the policing of women’s bodies, most Jews and our faith leaders, like most other people of faith in 21st century America, believe that a woman’s health, physical, psychological, emotional, and spiritual lives are of supreme value and her decisions about her body must remain in her hands. Decisions about women’s health and well-being must remain with women.
It is dark and dangerous to substitute the moral posture of certain legislators (based solely on those lawmakers’ religious beliefs vs. medical or public health concerns) for a woman’s own judgment, spiritual and theological discernment, and deliberation about her own physical and mental health and how her reproductive choices impact her future.
Restricting a woman’s choice does not save life; it endangers life. As a woman, I am deeply troubled by the impact S.B 23 would have on all women. As a rabbi, I am further concerned by the way that this proposed legislation violates Jewish values, law, and practices.
Thank you for your careful discernment and your attention to the bedrock religious liberties your proposed legislation threatens.